I woke up in the middle of the night on Tuesday. I guess it would have technically been early Wednesday morning. I was reeling a bit from the handful of brews polished off earlier in the evening, but my mind was on something other than the lingering headache. It was a feeling I wasn’t expecting to experience after the events that took place just a couple of hours before: remorse. It was like we got too much…too much fun, too much excitement, too much purse money. It felt like I didn’t deserve it for some reason. Luckily, that feeling subsided after thinking about the path to get there. A path we wouldn’t have even been on if it were not for that painful race out in Pittsburgh on July 16th where we traded a certain 1st or 2nd for a last place finish. If we had won, we wouldn’t have shipped back to Illinois for the Review Stakes race. If we didn’t ship back to Illinois for the Review, we wouldn’t have had a chance to experience the events of Tuesday night. There was no reason to feel like we got too much of anything. We deserved it.
It isn’t often were you can go to a race where you have a full compliment of ‘fans.’ Danny and I had been out to the Meadows for a race, Laura and I had been to Pocono Downs, but this was the first time we had the full crew: Greg, Danny, Laura and myself. Also, John, Jackie and Tyler Butenschoen were all down in Springfield for the race. If that wasn’t enough, Danny brought along a couple of friends (Darryl, Parker and Tanner) to round out the unofficial ‘In Over My Head Fan Club.’ We were all there because we all had a feeling something good was going to happen that day…well, except the Butenschoen’s. They had to work and take care of the horses! They may have had good feelings too. Anyway, ask any horse owner about having a big group come down to see a race you have a good feeling about and they will tell you a story about a time when their expected celebration turned out to be an uncomfortable, somber evening. A situation where their horse was expected to do well and the race went horribly. Horse got a bad trip, made a break, any number of things can happen to ruin a night. We were hoping that day would not create another one of those bad stories.
The one thing the general public didn’t realize was that we had a secret weapon that day. That weapon was none other than Danny Carey, fully dressed in his new colors, and he would be warming In Over My Head up. Danny has 3 starts as a trainer with 2 wins and 1 second. Between him and the Butenschoen’s, we had the best in the business getting Mo ready.
Because of rain the previous day, they had to race about 10 races from Monday’s card before ours, which pushed our race back from an anticipated 6pm start to about an 8pm start. As much as I love watching the races, Laura and I decided to step away from the track for awhile and take in the State Fairgrounds the only true way: on the skyride! For just $5 per person, you can ride in that cable car looking thing that slowly glides over endless rows of deep fried food stands, hot tub dealership booths, an ‘international village’ (which surprisingly wasn’t too busy), the midway rides and a plethora of other booths and food stands. We ended up getting a ‘milk shake’ for $4.95 that, quite frankly, I could have got for $1.50 at Dairy Queen (it was just soft serve ice cream), but hey, that’s what State Fairs are for. We ended up timing the ride perfectly because as we came back to the start, we got to see a bird’s eye view of the start of a race on the track. Very cool.
After a trip through the fairgrounds, the rest of the day was kind of a blur. I bet a few races, cashed a couple of tickets, but before I knew it we were just a few races away from ours. When Danny was out warming him up, I started to feel it. Those nerves were setting in. Gone were the high flying fun times of the skyride. My body started to feel heavy. My stomach started to tighten up. We were nearing race time.
There is something so unnerving about being able to stand and look at your horse before a big race and that is what we had that day. You don’t get to do that at most tracks as they come onto the track from the paddock, which is located a quite a ways away from the grandstand area. That isn’t the case in Springfield where the paddock is open and close. We could sit on some picnic tables near the grandstand and see In Over My Head standing there. He was a mere 20 yards from me. He was active: ears perked, looking over the stall at his future competitors, throwing his head around and at times he just appeared to be calmly watching the races unfolding out on the track. He is such a sharp looking horse. With all of the people we had down watching the race, there was a lot of activity around Mo. I decided to keep my distance. We didn’t need too many cooks in the kitchen. I just watched…and got more and more nervous.
I swear, races 6 through 10 went by in heartbeat. We were in the 11th and when the 10th race was complete, the group gathered over near Mo. Greg, Danny, John, Jackie, Tyler and Danny’s friends. I walked over, but left quickly. I just couldn’t take it anymore. Too tense. From there, I headed over to the betting counter. I had a $20 in my hand and planned on putting $10 to win and $10 to place on In Over My Head. I felt he was at least the second best horse in the race. The favorite, My Boy Luke, was certainly a worthy adversary. In his last 6 races, he had finished first 2 times and second 4 times. His times were fast and he would be tough to beat. However, as I got to the window, I had a change of heart. “$20 on the 2 (In Over My Head) to win,” I said. “Wow, everyone seems to be liking the 2,” the attendant replied. To that, I said, “That’s good, because I own half of him.”
I met Laura and said it was time to head up to the grandstand. She suggested saying a little prayer before we left, which was fine, but I didn’t want to pray for Mo to win. That would be too greedy; I just wanted him to race well. Laura said she’d take care of the win part of the prayer.
We found a spot in the grandstand near the wire with a good view of the track. Greg joined us a couple of minutes later and we both spent the next 10 minutes in a world of agonizing nervousness. He said it best when he commented on the fact when you only have one horse, everything rides on that race. There isn’t a big stable to fall back on. I think that is something that people miss when they see us so nervous. I’d just say think about going to a casino. You plan on gambling $250 dollars that night, but instead of $10 blackjack bets, you just throw it on one hand. A little more intense, right? Well, that’s us. One horse, one bet and a bucket full of nerves.
The tension was so high, that I didn’t even watch the horses as they approached the starting line. Instead, I was just looking down at the ground, hoping we were about to witness something good. When they reached the start line, I looked up and liked what was unfolding: Mo had driven out to the lead. My Boy Luke was gunning from his post position #4 as well, but Andy Miller (who seems to be a master of getting In Over My Head out of the starting gate well) made him work a bit around the first turn before he cleared. The first quarter was a snappy 27.1, one of the fastest that day on a relatively slow track. After a rather exciting start, the next half-mile was actually kind of bland. My Boy Luke continued to lead the way as we followed and he slowed the race down to a near crawl. The time as we reached the ¾ mile marker was 1.30.0, which is very slow for this group even on a bad track. With those easy fractions, it would be a sprint to the finish line.
Now we know Mo is a sprinter, but the problem was he was locked in. My Boy Luke was in the lead, we followed and two horses had moved up from the back in the outer flow, pinning In Over My Head on the rail. A thought flashed through my mind…we won’t do any better than 3rd. Without racing room, there would be no chance to use our speed to try and sprint past these other horses and as they neared 1/8th of a mile to go, I was thinking our trip down would have an average ending at best. That’s when things changed. My Boy Luke was pouring it on and starting to separate from the horses challenging from the outside, but he wasn’t separating from us. That created an opening and Andy Miller masterfully jumped at it within a split second of seeing it. He pulled Mo off the rail and within just a few steps, he was gaining on My Boy Luke. The problem was that we were running out of race. They were charging to the wire, now in full view of us looking on from the grandstand. It was a two horse race. In Over My Head was gaining ground with each step: past the race bike, up to My Boy Luke’s back, to his midsection…we just needed enough track to finish him off. It was then Mo seemed to take a gigantic couple of steps that got him eye to eye with the leader. There was still 50 feet of track left and with our momentum, the favorite was toast. Mo stormed past him and as they crossed the wire, In Over My Head, with a perfect drive from Andy Miller, had just captured the first big victory of his life.
To be honest with you, the final couple of seconds and the immediate time afterward was kind of a blur. I remember when Mo pulled even with My Boy Luke and knew at that point, the race was ours. I think I yelled something to the effect ‘We got it!’ to Greg and he said something like ‘this way!’ and motioned for me to follow. Greg had done his homework: he had already mapped out the fastest route to the winner’s circle! Very impressive game planning. Apparently, we took off sprinting about as fast as In Over My Head down the grandstand platform to a set of stairs and started going down them like we were a couple of cops chasing a suspect. Then we realized we forgot something rather important: Laura. Oops. I ran back up the steps and yelled for her. She wasn’t too far behind and was on cleanup duty as I had dropped my sunglasses and race program in the sprint. Now back together, the three of us winded our way through the belly of the grandstand and emerged on the ground level near the winner’s circle.
Shortly after we arrived, we were joined by the rest of our group: Danny and his friends, the Butenschoen’s and the stars of the track: Andy Miller and In Over My Head. Andy gave John a quick fist bump as Mo was led into the winners circle. We all followed and lined up for the picture (which you can see below). Lot’s of happy faces in there.

It wasn’t until after we left the winners circle when I realized just how special the day had become. Not only had we just won an important race, we had done so together. It is kind of rare to get everyone together to go to a race. It is even rarer to win that race. It is even rarer for that to happen in a stakes event. I thought back to our brief, but interesting history with In Over My Head. This is what we HOPED might happen when we bought him. I think we all actually envisioned a time when we would all be together in Springfield to watch a big victory and it actually happened. It really was a dream come true. I know in the future there will be more horses. Hopefully more big wins, but I can tell you with 100% certainty, that the victory in Springfield that day and the shared excitement with all of together will be something I will never ever forget.
We were the last race of the day and once done with the picture, picture ordering and cashing winning tickets, we headed back to the barn. On the way were lots of phone calls (Kirk, Mom, Dad and Grandma) and text messages. Darryl was able to locate a few cold Miller Lites. We popped the tops and had a big cheers to In Over My Head…I can’t remember the last time a beer tasted so good. From there we headed out for a late dinner and numerous recounts of the race and all the excitement that surrounded it. It was one of those days that you really don’t want to end, but we all reached a point of exhaustion soon enough. The stress and excitement of the race can really wear you down. It was time to call it a day, but it would be a day that I knew would be remembered and reminisced about many, many times.
I took a moment to look at past champions of this event. The Review Stake is certainly not a major race, but a true stakes race. Some of the biggest names in racing won it: Tar Heel in 1951, Race Time in 1964 and Bret Hanover in 1965. Recent speedsters such as Yankee Cruiser (2003) and Jeremy’s Jet (2006) won it in the last decade. To be fair, it was a bigger event in the past. With the blossoming slot purses in states like Pennsylvania, less horsemen ship their horses back to Illinois for the State Fair races, but that doesn’t matter. We made history, even if it was a small sliver of history. And, it marked the 10 year anniversary of another Carey owned horse victory: Carey’s Card Shark who won it in 1999. Let’s hope we can find another ‘W’ sometime between now and 2019.